Saturday, September 30, 2023
HomeTottenham HotspurThe Moral Dilemma of Permitting Kamila Valieva to Compete – An Outdated...

The Moral Dilemma of Permitting Kamila Valieva to Compete – An Outdated College Gymnastics Weblog

After testing constructive for a banned substance, it has been determined that Russian determine skater Kamila Valieva will probably be allowed to compete for the rest of the 2022 Olympics. It’s the newest chapter in a extremely uncommon doping case the place there is no such thing as a straightforward reply as to how this case needs to be resolved.

Kamila Valieva is just 15 years outdated and nearly everybody agrees that in a state of affairs the place a baby athlete is doped, it’s the adults who’re responsible. However however, this nonetheless creates an moral dilemma as there are two statements that the majority are in settlement with.

A) No athlete needs to be compelled to compete towards and/or lose a medal to an athlete who’s at present in violation of anti-doping necessities.

B) If the athlete in query is just 15 years outdated, she is just too younger to be thought-about at fault and any penalties needs to be inflicted on her help employees and never the kid in query.

Most readers would agree with these statements and that they’re each the fitting perspective to have. However each of those statements immediately contradict with one another and just one can virtually be carried out. In the end one among these two philosophies needed to be damaged and it was determined to reenter an athlete into the Olympics with a tainted doping file, permitting her to proceed competing towards athletes who examined clear.

The choice is extremely unpopular, even throughout the determine skating group the place followers have lengthy adored Valieva and wished to see her succeed. Whereas followers are disgusted on the prospect of an athlete with an impressive doping violation competing towards athletes who’ve handed the drug testing requirements, there may be extra injustice to be discovered.

The only most alarming byproduct of the Kamila Valieva case is it creates a precedent the place baby athletes are nearly resistant to anti-doping controls. Making a state of affairs the place the youngest and most susceptible athletes in sports activities might be doped with impunity by their coaches. That alone would represent a human tragedy if such ways turn into widespread because of this case.

However there may be additionally a extra instant dilemma for the athletes who will probably be competing towards Valieva through the 2022 Olympics. Whereas it isn’t unusual for Olympic medals to be stripped and redistributed, it’s extremely uncommon for a priority to be raised relating to vacated medals previous to the beginning time of the competitors in query.

If Kamila Valieva presses forward and competes in 2022 ladies’s singles, it might be some of the absurd competitions in Olympic historical past the place athletes will probably be competing for a medal realizing the gold-medal favourite could later be dominated ineligible. How is an athlete imagined to compete beneath these circumstances and never let that influence her efficiency? How does an athlete determine how a lot threat to soak up a contest the place it’s unclear precisely who they should beat to be able to win?

Think about being the 4th place finisher on this situation? Meaning a determine skater must watch a medal ceremony from the stands realizing full effectively that there’s a risk she’s will later be dominated because the rightful bronze medalist and is about to be unfairly denied her proper to partake in an Olympic medal ceremony. Denying her the flexibility to expertise what is usually the one most essential second within the profession of an Olympian.

However Valieva’s presence has compelled occasion organizers to cancel any medal ceremony she is predicted to take part in till this case is resolved. This implies as many as 25 Olympians will probably go dwelling and not using a medal that rightfully belongs to them. Creating the chance that these athletes will solely be honored in what quantities to a make-up ceremony that doesn’t have the identical aura as a “true” Olympic medal ceremony.

It isn’t my intent to argue that the choice to let Valieva compete was incorrect. The skaters competing towards Valieva have issues/wants that have to be thought-about. However so do the issues/wants of Kamila Valieva herself. This can be a baby who has examined constructive for a banned substance. The doping of a kid is with out query a type of baby abuse and to penalize Kamila is akin to penalizing a baby for her personal abuse.

It’s a sickening thought to have and the age of the athlete in query is what makes this case so heartbreaking. The doping of a 15 12 months outdated is tragic and upon the discovering of such a revelation, it creates an moral dilemma of what to do subsequent when there is no such thing as a resolution that’s honest to all events concerned.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments